Color Scales, Henri and the Winter’s Studio Group

Robert Henri, Young Buck of Tesuque Pueblo, 1916

Recently, I have been studying the intensity palettes of Robert Henri. These studies were part of a group effort by artists that surrounded Henri in 1915-1916. These included the artists George Bellows, John Sloan as well as Charles Winter, Randall Davey and H. G. Maratta. These meetings took place in Charles Winter’s studio. The group was interested in studying color intensity and coming up with a language that could identify color intensity in a practical way. Maratta had already explored this aspect of color in his Spectrum Color Chart patent of 1909. In this patent, Maratta identifies 5 levels that a color can be diminished by from its pure state to its near neutralization in a hue (a hue is a color that is neutralized but still maintains the character of its color- it blueness or its redness etc. Hue is used as such only in Maratta’s system and by those associated with the group of artists surrounding Henri).

But what Maratta had not achieved was a complete language to identify each color’s intensity and to create a scale of such intensity [In 1905 Albert Munsell will create a sphere that will include intensity (called chroma in Munsell’s version) as part of the spherical design and measured radially]. One of the first activities by the group was a creation of a chart that identified where each color in the spectrum in its most intense state fell in relationship to the complete spectrum of 12 colors. The intensity range was identified as 13 at the top of the scale and 1 at the bottom of the scale. So, 13 was the most intense and 1 was the least intense. The scale did not include every number between 1 and 13 but were actually numbered as follows in descending intensity: 13, 11, 9, 7, 5, 3, 1. Below this was a series of neutralized tones identified as ‘s’.

Therefore, each color received a number that identified where it fell in its most intense state as a pure, unadulterated color and from this top point, included all those mixes in descending intensity to ‘s’. What the group found was that the color YG was situated at 13 in its most intense state and therefore had a descending range down the entire scale to ‘s’. This is the only color that the group found that spanned the entire chart. At level 11 is G, GB, OY, Y, YG and G (reduced one register). Level 9 included a reduction in intensity of all the above plus B, R, RO, and O at their most intense state. Level 7 included all the above reduced one level and BP and PR at their most intense. Level 5 included all the above plus P at its most intense. Level 3, 1, and ‘s’ include all the 12 colors of the spectrum reduced at each level descending to near neutralization at level ‘s’.

If we look at the 12 colors of the spectrum they appear at their highest intensity at different levels. These are the colors in their pure, unadulterated state. Henri and his group identified where they fell on the chart by the indication of a number in the exponents place:

  • VR7
  • R9
  • RO9
  • O9
  • OY11
  • Y11
  • YG13
  • G11
  • GB11
  • B9
  • BP7
  • P5

But what was particularly interesting about the intensity chart was the idea of color scale. Henri and the other artists involved with the experiments used the term scale in a musical sense. In regards to paint, each color was reduced in intensity by it’s hue. An example: G was reduced by G hue. Secondly, each color scale ended with the addition of the complement. This was important because it showed how each scale was, in a sense, circular. The G scale ended with the addition of the R hue added to the lowest intensity G (at ‘s’). If the scale were to continue it would slowly become the R scale. Moving from the ‘s’ level, the color at its most reduced intensity, one would slowly begin to add R hue in less and less amounts to R until one reached R in its pure state.

Robert Henri, Mary Fanton Roberts, 1917

This circular aspect of the color scales I found most intriguing. And this insight effected all the artists involved. Sloan discusses color scales in “The Gist of Art” and like Henri uses this insight from 1915 onward. It becomes a method to visually allow color to subtly move across the surface of the canvas. This created a feeling of depth and an inherent sense of the movement of color in the composition. Each artist became attuned to the power of manipulating a color’s intensity to achieve various ends. Henri uses a color scale to take an area that is basically, say O, and create variety within that O area by painting it in various intensities of the O scale. This added an ‘aliveness’ to what should have been a flat color area. Henri also created depth by moving that O scale toward its complement of B allowing the O to travel spatially backward into the canvas. These are just two examples among many that Henri speaks of through his paintings at this time as well as in the “Art Spirit”.

Color Spectrum Recession, the Cool Side

 

Judith Reeve, “Limes”, 6″x 8″, oil on linen, 2017

In my last blog, I focused on creating a feeling of recession in the image of the “Nectarines” by using the warm side of the color spectrum. Color temperature recession along the spectrum of 12 colors is much easier to achieve through the warm colors. Warm colors naturally project giving the feeling that an object or an area of space comes closer to the picture plane. Cooler colors naturally recede and allow those planes that are moving away from the picture plane to recede as well as, highlighting the turning away of forms.

This week, I want to focus on the cooler side of the spectrum band of 12 colors. The cooler side begins with YG and recedes along the spectrum to G, GB, B, BV, V and VR. VR is the turning point back to the warm side of the spectrum. In my painting of “Limes”, which is primarily a very cool image, I begin the recession at the YG and move toward the V with just a hint of the VR. The lightest color was, in fact, the VR+Wht to act as the highlight and return the projection back to the warm side. Although, with the addition of white to the VR, it acts as a cool compared to the YG. Here is the palette I used.

Movement from YG to PR

I attempted to use all the colors along the spectrum with very little change or intermixing. I did add two additional G by mixing the G+GB to increase the range in the greens (this was mixed prior to actual painting). Also, I did use the neutral along the shadow edge to create the feeling of transition. This neutral, by comparison, appears warm. It is important to vary the feeling of the color temperature to achieve recession of the form and not to be too rigid in this experiment. Plus, the neutral will take on its own color depending on the adjacent colors near it (simultaneous contrast of color, Chevreul).

So, the limes follow the cool color recession as follows: VR+W, YG+W, YG, G, N, GB, GB/G (reflected light), with a touch of BV near the edge. The movement of space from foreground to background: GB (with GB+W on top), GB+BV, BV, V. The cast shadows: GB+BV with the N near the shadow edge to give that feeling of a red emerging from the darkest dark (Goethe’s colored edges). You will notice that I did not use B in the painting. What I did use was B hue mixed by GB+BV. This created the illusion of B without the B projecting forward (the B wanted to project forward because I was using cobalt blue, which is a lighter value than the GB and BV). Value plays a role in form recession as well and I maintained the lowering of value incorporated as part of the color recession. The B hue had the right value to take the form back.

Both experiments were very enlightening- the warm recession and the cool recession along the spectrum. It is good to have several tools in one’s toolbox to achieve a certain result. In this case, I used value, color temperature and color spectrum recession. I could have used instead a reduction of color intensity by the addition of the root color’s hue to my local color to get the form to recede. Or I could have used a variation of scale (John Sloan, On Drawing and Painting, p. 116) where a color returns to its complement after passing through a neutral hue. Or I could have alternated the color temperature W-C-W-C-W as suggested by Henri in the Art Spirit. Having a variety of ways to move form allows the artist the maximum opportunity to get the results one desires.